HHKB Studio review: you have to want the trackpoint

The HHKB Studio raises a lot of questions. Questions like “is that a trackpoint?” and “how do you even type on it?” from people who aren’t familiar with the Happy Hacking Keyboard (HHKB) and different questions from people who are.

The quickest way to explain the HHKB Studio is that it’s the Bluetooth version of the cult-favorite Happy Hacking Keyboard, plus a ThinkPad-esque touchpoint, plus four touch-sensitive gesture control areas, minus electrocapacitive Topre switches, all for $329, or about the price of the HHKB Professional Hybrid Type-S. It’s available for preorder with an ETA of November.

This is not an everybody flavor.

The Good

  • A joy to type on
  • Trackpoint works well
  • Thick PBT keycaps and smooth, quiet switches
  • Remappable

The Bad

  • Chassis is kind of ugly
  • Gesture pads are unintuitive
  • Limited keycap compatibility
  • $330? That’s Topre money

How we rate and review products

The pitch for the HHKB Studio is that it’s a portable, high-quality all-in-one computer input device that you never need to take your hands off of. You can toss it in your bag and use it with whatever computer you’re on. This is the basic philosophy behind the Happy Hacking Keyboard in general; the Studio just takes it a little further for those of us who don’t navigate entirely by keyboard shortcuts.

You have to really want a trackpoint for this to make any sort of sense

The trackpoint means you don’t need a mouse, and the four touch-sensitive gesture pads can act as arrow keys, scrub through footage, control volume, swap between apps or virtual desktops, scroll through websites, or more. The keyboard is fully remappable, and you can have up to four keymapping profiles in the internal memory. So you can have one setup for video editing and separate ones for Mac or Windows or whatnot. It can pair with up to four Bluetooth devices, has a USB-C port for a wired connection, and — for the first time in an HHKB — it uses standard MX-compatible switches as opposed to the legendary Topre electrocapacitive dome switches in the Professional models.

This is really not an everybody flavor.

First off, it’s three hundred and thirty US dollars. Second, the Happy Hacking Keyboard, while perfect, is pretty niche, and people who love it tend to want Topre. The idea of an HHKB with MX switches is borderline sacrilege. There are plenty of cheaper boards with the HHKB layout and better keycap compatibility. You have to really want a trackpoint for this to make any sort of sense.

If anyone in the world is the target audience, though, it’s me. I love compact mechanical keyboards. I’m already used to the HHKB layout. I love Topre but not exclusively. I would spend $330 on a keyboard — not that I need another one. And I’ve seriously considered buying one with a trackpoint except it didn’t have split backspace.

Which is all to say: I’m totally sold on the concept.

The HHKB Studio comes with 45g silenced linear switches made by Kailh. The board is hot-swappable and compatible with three- and five-pin MX-style switches. Photo: Nathan Edwards / The Verge

The keyboard part of the HHKB Studio is lovely to type on. I have [an embarrassing number of] mechanical keyboards in my office, and I like this one the best. I got used to the keyboard and trackpoint within minutes — I haven’t touched my mouse in a week — and the gesture bars are the only thing I’m not totally on board with. The keymapping software is good for a stock keyboard and mostly easy to grasp, though it has a couple of weird quirks and omissions. Switching between devices and between keymap profiles is kind of counterintuitive, but it’s manageable. Battery life is great.

I haven’t touched my mouse in a week

I’ve used it with my work MacBook, my Windows desktop, my Chromebook, and — god help me — a Samsung phone in DeX mode. There are always weird issues that crop up working cross-platform, but the HHKB Studio has done what it’s supposed to do. The keyboard feels amazing, the trackpoint works. The gesture pads… exist.

I did not expect the keyboard to feel as good to type on as it does. Instead of Topre switches, it comes with MX-compatible 45g silenced linears made by Kailh. Topre switches are famously tactile — it’s kind of their whole deal — so linears seem like a weird choice at first, but it works. Between these switches, the thick PBT keycaps, and the steel switch plate, it sounds and feels right for an HHKB, with a deep, pleasantly thocky sound and snappy return. It’s not the same as Topre, but the vibes are right.

If you don’t like the feel of the stock switches, you can change them for any of thousands of compatible switches. The board supports both three-pin and five-pin MX switches. This is good! Hot-swappable sockets are table stakes for mechanical keyboards these days, and it softens the blow of losing Topre. (You can swap out the domes on a Topre board, but it’s a much more finicky procedure, and there are far fewer options.)

The keycaps are thick PBT and feel great under your fingers, which is good, because you’re kind of stuck with them. Even though the keyboard accepts MX-compatible keycaps, the G, H, and B keys are sculpted to make room for the trackpoint, and standard keycaps won’t fit on those keys unless you bust out a Dremel. And the 6u space bar uses 6.25u stabilizer spacing, which means you can’t swap that out easily, either. Chase Gutierrez, the HHKB product manager at PFU America — the US branch of the company that makes the Happy Hacking Keyboard — told me PFU considered other options but said this was the best compromise after consulting with “many keyboard enthusiasts globally” since it’s more compatible with standard aftermarket keycap sets. PFU does at least plan to release the 3D files for its 6u space bar so people can make their own.

Oh, and if you can’t touch type: good luck! The Studio’s black-on-charcoal keycaps are true to HHKB tradition in that it’s very hard to read the legends in most lighting. Granted, completely blank keycaps are also an HHKB tradition, and they could have gone that way, but it’d be nice if the Studio came in classic HHKB white, too.

The G, H, and B keys are cut away to make room for the trackpoint, which limits keycap compatibility. Photography by Nathan Edwards / The Verge

The trackpoint works just like the classic ThinkPad trackpoint, and it took me no time at all to adapt to it. You can swap sensitivity levels on the fly with a set of function key combinations, which is nice for working with larger screens. I got so used to using it in just a few days that when I switched back to a different keyboard, I kept reaching for a trackpoint that wasn’t there.

The gesture bars will take some getting used to. They’re remappable, like the rest of the keys, and that includes function layers, giving you up to four sets of touch controls per profile. By default, the left side and front pads simulate the arrow keys, the right sidewall is a scroll wheel, and the right front pad alt-tabs through your applications. On my Mac, I put volume controls on the left side pad, under a function layer.

There are four gesture bars: one on each side and two on the front. The little bars indicate their location so you can find them by feel. Photo by Nathan Edwards / The Verge

These are the weakest part of the HHKB Studio. There’s no feedback whatsoever, and stroking the side or front of the keyboard frame is not a way I usually interact with a computer. In the keymap tool, you can toggle them off individually and per profile — so if you only want them on when you’re editing video or working with a specific computer, you can do that. I haven’t quite gotten to the point of disabling them, but I don’t really use them much, either.

  • The trackpoint on my first review unit had frequent jitters over Bluetooth on every computer I tried it with. PFU sent me a second unit, which only jittered once on my MacBook when I turned on my Bluetooth headphones, but it’s been otherwise stable. The Studio has a two-year warranty.
  • The keyboard remapping tool (for both Mac and Windows) is surprisingly comprehensive, almost VIA-esque, though there are certain keys combinations it won’t let you remap, like Fn + Q (which it uses for Bluetooth pairing), and it weirdly omits common media control keys like play / pause, forward, and back. There’s no on-the-fly remapping, and you have to have the keyboard connected via USB in order to write new keymaps.
  • On my work MacBook, the function keys (Fn + number row keys) defaulted to function keys rather than the default Mac controls and shortcuts. I had to use Karabiner-Elements to fix this.
  • The HHKB Studio keymap tool gives you four keyboard profiles with up to four layers each. You can remap the gesture bars or turn them off individually. Image: PFU

    • The keyboard can store up to four layers per profile (the base layer and three function layers) and four profiles. But the tool doesn’t carry over keymap changes between layers or between profiles, which results in some busy work. When I’m working on a Mac, I swap Cmd and Ctrl; I had to do that on both the standard layer and each function layer in order for it to stick. Most key remapping software doesn’t require that.
    • The Studio doesn’t automatically switch keymap profiles when you switch devices. So switching from Mac to Windows involves, for example, hitting Fn + Ctrl + 1 to switch computers and Fn + C + 1 to switch keymaps. This is silly!
    • The case, unfortunately, is butt ugly functional rather than beautiful. The elegant lines of the HHKB Professional have gone right out the damn window. The front bezel is enormous to accommodate the mouse keys. The bottom frame is space gray and juts out a couple of millimeters on each side to help guide your fingers to the touch-sensitive areas on the top frame, and the whole thing looks pretty dated.
    • The frame is all plastic, but that isn’t a problem. The HHKB Professional has been all plastic for years, and these things are designed to be portable.

    The elegant lines of the HHKB Professional have gone right out the damn window

    • The keyboard is powered by four AA batteries; PFU Limited says it can go up to three months on a charge.
    • Plugging the HHKB Studio into USB doesn’t charge the batteries, and it doesn’t automatically switch the keyboard’s connection to USB, either. You have to do that manually. It does stop the keyboard from using battery power, though, which means that if you want to switch it back to Bluetooth mode, you need to do that before you unplug it. Otherwise, it shuts off, and you have to toggle the power switch to turn it back on again.
    • When I asked why it wasn’t Topre, PFU sent a long reply that boiled down to: we wanted to make something quieter than the HHKB Professional series, hence the silent linear switches, but also wanted to give people the freedom to change them out if they wanted to. The Studio is quieter than my “silenced” Leopold FC660C with Topre switches. It’s also surely easier to cram a trackpoint onto an MX-style PCB than a Topre one. Those domes are fidgety to align.
    • The Studio’s Kailh switches aren’t just a recolor. They’re most similar to Deep Sea Islets, but they have different springs. The Islets feel a little heavier and a bit smoother. Both switches have very long springs (around 20mm) compared to their travel length (about 3.8mm). I really like the Studio’s switches and was considering getting a set, but I don’t like them enough to pay $2.50 a pop when the Islets are about 70 cents.

    It all comes down to the trackpoint. If you want the trackpoint, all of the HHKB Studio’s quirks and limitations can fade into the background. It works, and it works really well, and if I still traveled for work, I’d buy one last week.

    If you aren’t already sold on the trackpoint, the HHKB Studio is a tougher sell. It is a really, really nice keyboard. I love the layout. I love the way it feels and sounds when I type on it. It has better keycaps than any off-the-shelf board I’ve ever used, and the switches are great, too.

    I don’t love that it’s $330, uses a nonstandard space bar (who does that?!), and only comes in one color. The gesture pads? Eh. I can take ’em or leave ’em. If you don’t want the trackpoint, you have many better options, including the HHKB Professional Hybrid Type-S, for less money.

    But if you do want a really nice keyboard with a trackpoint and the perfect layout, the HHKB Studio is a real joy.



    S'il vous plaît entrez votre commentaire!
    S'il vous plaît entrez votre nom ici

    Le plus populaire